We actually have a master thread for this in What-ifs. You can post this there.
Tracy was once inspired by a visit from Richard Nixon in a dream to support the Republicans, and Donaghy had early convinced him thanks to the GOP having Lincoln and loving guns.
Thread relocated and merged.
as for the question-
Liz: She would tell everyone she's voting for Obama, yeah, but there's like an eighty percent chance she'd secretly vote Romney
Jack: Mitt Romney's (or his oldest son, Jezba)
Tracy: Dennis Kucinich
Jenna: Obama, yeah
Kenneth: he would write in God's name, but per Jack, "That's Republican. We count those." So, Romney.
Twofer, Pete, Cerie, Frank, Lutz, Grizz, Dot Com: all Obama