None of whom crossed party lines between the Democrats and the Republicans though.
This one I found interesting:
1820 - William Plummer, Sr. (D/R-NH)
In this well-known act of 'patriotism', Plummer apparently changed his vote from Democratic-Republican candidate James Monroe to fellow Democratic-Republican John Quincy Adams (who was not a candidate) supposedly after concluding that no President other than George Washington should be elected with the unanimous vote of the Electoral College.
Legend.
He held a speech to his fellow electors declaring that the reason he voted against Monroe/Tompkins was that they were both highly incompetent.