Taking everything into account, have these posters had a positive or negative...

[Eraserhead]

BRTD- Positive
Keystone Phil- A lot of both at times but positive overall
Eraserhead - N/A
Straha- Positive
Xahar - Slightly negative
Benconstine - Slightly negative
Kingofthebenchpress - Positive because all he really did was bring everyone a few laughs
opebo - Very positive
NDN/Mint - Positive
jamespol - Very mixed, has been annoing at times and highly amusing at others
Dazzleman - Wasn't around for him really but negative as far as I can tell
Killerpollo - Not really sure but i wanted to see what other people thought
J.J. - Barely positive, he's brought some laughs
downwithdaleft - Positive
South Park Conservative - Barely positive to neutral
BushOklahoma - Barely positive but he is a really nice guy
Willy Woz/FREEDOMNOTBUSH - Positive since he was a real oddball and I tend to enjoy oddballs
HappyWarrior - Positive

I updated the list with my thoughts.

[I spent the winter writing songs about getting better]

BRTD - Recused
Keystone Phil - Barely positive due to the local PA insight even if it's usually wrong.
Eraserhead - Positive
Straha - A lot of both but barely positive overall. He did make "epic fail" a forum phrase after all.
Xahar - Positive
Benconstine - Negative
Kingofthebenchpress - Negative
opebo - Duh. Is this even questionable? Imagine the forum without him.
NDN/Mint - Negative. Though he only got so bad very recently now for some reason.
jamespol - Positive. He's funny albeit unintentionally.
Dazzleman - Negative
Killerpollo - Negative
J.J. - Negative. He went beyond amusing even.
downwithdaleft - Mostly negative...but he did get texasindy to leave. So barely negative.
South Park Conservative - Negative
BushOklahoma - Neither really beyond some amusing posts. So a net small positive.
Willy Woz/FREEDOMNOTBUSH - LOL. Negative.

[Lunar]

where am I?


and I refuse to offer an honest opinion on any controversial poster

[HappyWarrior]

where am I?

[Eraserhead]

where am I?

I'll add you two if you want but everyone is just going to say "positive".

[Lunar]

I'm joshin' -- obviously you're choosing controversial people

I don't like being judged thx

[Eraserhead]

I'm joshin' -- obviously you're choosing controversial people

I don't like being judged thx

Then I shall remove you.

[specific_name]

King of the Bench Press is one of my favorite trolls. I confess that I've thought about going to other forums using his handle, pretending to be an anabolic steroid user with malformed political opinions. So many amusing situations would ensue...

[Grumpier Than Uncle Joe]

BRTD - positive when he discusses issues
Keystone Phil - very positive
Eraserhead - Very positive
Straha - Positive
Xahar - I love the lil guy - positive
Benconstine - Positive
Kingofthebenchpress - No, negative
opebo - Positive
NDN/Mint - Positive
jamespol - Negative-
Dazzleman - Positive
Killerpollo - Negative (where did he go anyway?)
J.J. - very positive
downwithdaleft - positive
South Park Conservative - positive
BushOklahoma - positive
Willy Woz/FREEDOMNOTBUSH - One of the worst ever
HappyWarrior - very positive

[JSojourner]

I am pretty much on the same page as GM3...with exceptions noted in bold

BRTD - positive when he discusses issues
Keystone Phil - very positive
Eraserhead - Very positive
Straha - Before my time, mostly...
Xahar - I love the lil guy - positive
Benconstine - Positive
Kingofthebenchpress - Negative.  What next?  Descriptions of his bodily functions?
opebo - Positive
NDN/Mint - Positive
jamespol - Negative-
Dazzleman - Positive
Killerpollo - Too lazy to review.  Who?
J.J. - positive
downwithdaleft - Not the worst ever, but almost.
South Park Conservative - Negative ideas, nice person
BushOklahoma - positive
Willy Woz/FREEDOMNOTBUSH - One of the worst ever
HappyWarrior - very positive

[Bacon King]

BRTD- positive
Keystone Phil- positive
Eraserhead- positive
Straha- negative
Xahar- neutral
Benconstine- negative
Kingofthebenchpress- negative but hilarious
opebo- positive
NDN/Mint- neutral
jamespol- neutral
Dazzleman- neutral
Killerpollo- negative
J.J.- negative
downwithdaleft- negative
South Park Conservative- neutral
BushOklahoma- neutral
Willy Woz/FREEDOMNOTBUSH- negative but hilarious
HappyWarrior- positive

[© tweed]

BRTD: positive
Keystone Phil: positive
Eraserhead: not really very influential, not a dominant personality
Straha: negative
Xahar: slightly negative
Benconstine: negative
Kingofthebenchpress: zero
opebo: positive
NDN/Mint: zero
jamespol: negative, but doesn't really matter
Dazzleman: slightly positive
Killerpollo: negative
J.J.: very slightly positive in a weird way
downwithdaleft: negative
South Park Conservative: slightly negative
BushOklahoma: wouldn't matter if not a mod, but slightly negative
Willy Woz/FREEDOMNOTBUSH: not terribly relevant
HappyWarrior: irrelevant

[Hash]

BRTD: slight negative
Keystone Phil: neutral, meh
Eraserhead: neutral
Straha: slight negative
Xahar: positive
Benconstine: negative
Kingofthebenchpress: very negative
opebo: slight negative
NDN/Mint: neutral
jamespol: negative
Dazzleman: ?
Killerpollo: negative
J.J.: slight negative
downwithdaleft: negative
South Park Conservative: neutral
BushOklahoma: slight positive
Willy Woz/FREEDOMNOTBUSH: negative
HappyWarrior: positive

[exopolitician]

BRTD - Negative but personally hes neutral to me.
Keystone Phil - Positive.
Eraserhead - Positive.
Straha - Negative.
Xahar - Positive.
Benconstine - Eh...Positive?
Kingofthebenchpress - Negative...but in an entertaining way?
opebo - I guess positive....but see above.
NDN/Mint - Positive.
jamespol - Negative...but improving.
Dazzleman - Who?
Killerpollo _ ^
J.J. - Negative
downwithdaleft - Negative
South Park Conservative - Negative
BushOklahoma - Positive
Willy Woz/FREEDOMNOTBUSH - Negative
HappyWarrior - Positive.

[DownWithTheLeft]

LOL @ ppl who put postitive for Xahar

Other than that I'd say positive for all the people that aren't trolls/dual accounts

[Matt Damon™]

The only positive ones are me, mint and killerpollo. Eraserhead, J.J. and Happywarrior are neutral. The rest are all negative.

[Tyrion The Unbanned]

wow, xahar is getting really pissed about the stalking thing