Sean Hannity vs. Bill O'Reilly

[President Punxsutawney Phil]

Figured this would have interesting results.

[Greedo punched first]

Hannity. No contest.

[Mr. Smith]

O'Reilly by far.

The creep with some intellect is better than than the creep that is just a big hackish nixon.

[Associate Justice PiT]

     Tucker Carlson.

[Grumpier Than Uncle Joe]

Hannity is unwatchable.  O'Reilly was tolerable.  As people?  Who knows about Hannity.

[ApatheticAustrian]

BillO, no contest.

i prefer a partisan asshole to a value-less disgusting hack.

[Orthogonian Society Treasurer]

     Tucker Carlson.

[Santander]

Bill O

[Xing]

As a commentator, O'Reilly. As a person, Hannity, provided there aren't similar revelations about him.

[RaphaelDLG]

Bill O'Reilly is easily better as a broadcaster and also better politically, though the gap was closed somewhat in later years on the latter dimension.

As people, EASILY Hannity, in a complete walk.  He's reportedly kind and warm to the FN libs, whereas O'Reilly... besides the obvious, was hated by pretty much everyone.

[Beet]

     Tucker Carlson.

Yuck.

[Kingpoleon]

Bill O'Reilly is easily better as a broadcaster and also better politically, though the gap was closed somewhat in later years on the latter dimension.

As people, EASILY Hannity, in a complete walk.  He's reportedly kind and warm to the FN libs, whereas O'Reilly... besides the obvious, was hated by pretty much everyone.

This. I voted for O'Reilly, though.

[RaphaelDLG]

Bill O'Reilly is easily better as a broadcaster and also better politically, though the gap was closed somewhat in later years on the latter dimension.

As people, EASILY Hannity, in a complete walk.  He's reportedly kind and warm to the FN libs, whereas O'Reilly... besides the obvious, was hated by pretty much everyone.

This. I voted for O'Reilly, though.

Same, as big of an asshole as he is.

[Catholics vs. Convicts]

O'Reilly by far.

The creep with some intellect is better than than the creep that is just a big hackish nixon.

This, but both still make me sick.

[Hydera]

Voted for the perv because he's less socially reactionary than the other one.

[President Punxsutawney Phil]

BillO is winning so far, 9 to 12.

[fhtagn]

Bill O'Reilly is easily better as a broadcaster and also better politically, though the gap was closed somewhat in later years on the latter dimension.

As people, EASILY Hannity, in a complete walk.  He's reportedly kind and warm to the FN libs, whereas O'Reilly... besides the obvious, was hated by pretty much everyone.

This. I voted for O'Reilly, though.

This for me as well.
Same, as big of an asshole as he is.

[100% pro-life no matter what]

Hannity, easily, but Tucker Carlson is the best primetime FOX News host.

[ApatheticAustrian]

Hannity, easily, but Tucker Carlson is the best primetime FOX News host.

i understand hannity if you go for hackerish purity but carlson, on the other hand, is less pure - maybe even less than BillO - than hannity but a better host.....what exactly are you going for, if i may ask?

[100% pro-life no matter what]

Hannity, easily, but Tucker Carlson is the best primetime FOX News host.

i understand hannity if you go for hackerish purity but carlson, on the other hand, is less pure - maybe even less than BillO - than hannity but a better host.....what exactly are you going for, if i may ask?

A few things:

-Being a strong conservative- all three mostly are

But, then, it comes to style.  O'Reilly has always come off as a little arrogant and smug to me, while I enjoy Hannity's show.  But, the best entertainment is watching Tucker Carlson and some liberal agitator argue on live television!

[Goldwater]

Hannity, I guess. I never liked O'Reilly.

[Vosem]

Hard to say as people, but O'Reilly's show was much better; he was consistent in his positions and while he was hackish he at least came off as saying things he believed in rather than swaying with the weathervane of whatever's popular on the right at a given moment.