Charlie Baker/Larry Hogan vs Joe Manchin/John Bel Edwards?

[Cyrusman]

Two liberal republicans against two conservative democrats.

Who would you vote for and what would the map be?

[Matty]

This would be like dividing by zero given the extreme rural and urban trends of late.

It could very well cause a hole in the spacetime continuum.

[Agonized-Statism]

Senator Joe Manchin (D-WV) / Governor John Bel Edwards (D-LA) ✔
Governor Charlie Baker (R-MA) / Governor Larry Hogan (R-MD)

[Christian Man]

It would be a strange election electorally. West Virginia would flip for almost any other Republican, but they'd likely vote for a moderate Manchin over a liberal like Baker, as would most Southerners, although this wouldn't be as apparent in Appalachia, as Manchin would not win over the ancestrally unionist areas, as well as fare relatively poorly in parts of suburbia.

Governor John Bel Edwards/Senator Joe Manchin: 49.7%/293 E.C.
Governor Charlie Baker/Governor Larry Hogan: 48.3/245 E.C.