Wouldn't this be crazy?

[Alcon]

Zell Miller vs. some liberal Republican (Lincoln Chaffee [sp]?). Miller would take the deep south, I'd bet. However, I'd bet nearly every single state would become a total toss-up. It would be a battle of party loyalty versus position loyalty.

What would a map look like?

[7,052,770]

wow, that'd be crazy

[Doug D. Wise]

I don't know how to do the map but how about WITH HILLARY?!?!?!?
AL Miller
AK Miller
AZ Chafee
AR Miller
CA Clinton
CO Chafee
CT Clinton
DC Clinton
DE Chafee
FL Chafee
GA Miller
HI Clinton
ID Miller
IL Clinton
IN Miller
IA Chafee
KS Miller
KY Miller
LA Chafee
ME Chafee
MD Clinton
MA Clinton
MI Clinton
MN Clinton
MS Miller
MO Chafee
MT Miller
NE Miller
NV Chafee
NH Chafee
NJ Clinton
NM Chafee
NY Clinton
NC Miller
ND Miller
OH Chafee
OK Miller
OR Chafee
PA Clinton
RI Clinton
SC Miller
SD Miller
TN Miller
TX Miller
UT Miller
VT Clinton
VA Miller
WA Clinton
WV Chafee
WN Chafee
WY Miller

[Alcon]

That would be your map, which I partially agree with, although I disagree in some states. It would be a case of liberals vs. moderates vs. conservatives, as opposed to Democrats vs. Republicans.

The tally would be:

Clinton 227
Miller 178
Chafee 133

[Lunar]

In a steady 3-way race it's very difficult to tell which state will go which.  All it takes is for that third candidate to do well to completely reverse the expected outcome (Montana '92).

The reason why every state is a tossup is because the two candidates are so similar.  It'd be like running John Kerry vs Wes Clark.

[I spent the winter writing songs about getting better]

In a steady 3-way race it's very difficult to tell which state will go which.  All it takes is for that third candidate to do well to completely reverse the expected outcome (Montana '92).

The reason why every state is a tossup is because the two candidates are so similar.  It'd be like running John Kerry vs Wes Clark.

they aren't similar. They differ on almost every issue. I'd vote for Chaffee no question.

[Erc]

In a Clinton-Zell race, Clinton would beat Zell by a good 6 points.

Add Chaffee, and the race goes to Miller by default.

Republican voters like Zell...election season is long enough that Zell & Miller can be differentiated.

Expect a good number of votes for Chaffee in NY to be on the "Liberal" ticket, though...