A president can be an HP and still be a good president.
I don't think Reagan was an HP. But I also think he wasn't a great president. He is very much overrated and gets too much credit and not enough blame for the things that happened during (and right) after his time in office.
He’s overrated by Republicans, but the Democrats on this Thread are acting like he’s the reincarnation of Hitler.
True. Off course he is not. He is not some mass-murderer. Not even Trump comes close to being like Hitler and he is both an HP and a very bad president.
For me, Reagan belongs somewhere between 10 and 20. Just like Obama.