Based on what I know about him from the past, he seems to have quite a different background than the average Atlas poster. I think that's part of the perceived issue, and something with which many on this forum have a hard time dealing.
Care to elaborate, or would that be breaking confidentiality or something?
I can see how that sort of thing might lead to misunderstandings and unwarranted HP votes in general... but man, that Elliot Rodger line was just
so utterly inexcusable and beyond the pale no matter your background.