2004 - Bush had the prettier face; Kerry was attractive until one glanced at his face
Amazingly, people did (and do) find Kerry attractive. Different looks for different folks, I guess.
I always thought both George W. Bush and John Kerry looked like stereotypes of WASP-y upper crust semi-inbreeding. W had the small chin, the Roman nose, the big ears - he practically could have been a stand-in for an obscure member of the British royal family. Kerry's face is so long and his chin is so big that he's like some kind of purebred show dog where things got out of hand.
But no matter who the GOP nominee is, the media will rake Hillary over the coals for looking "old" while giving her paunchy, wrinkly male opponent who isn't much younger a pass.