And the Palestinian Arabs are rightful residents of the area as well. There's no point in arguing with that. That's why roughly 2/3rds of Mandatory Palestine was carved out for them when it was partitioned, with the remaining third remaining in British hands until it was eventually ceded to the Jewish reclamation movement.
In that case it's no problem if we move all the Israelis to Antarctican Peninsula, I mean it's much bigger than Israel.
Quality of the land count more than the amount of land.
Neither parcel of land has significant natural reserves, at least Israel didn't until they spent decades on innovation.
Regardless, four wars of genocidal aggression and winding up with what you started with sounds pretty good to me. But as long as the Hashemites are able to keep their murderous grip on Jordan, the conflict is unresolveable.