Is it more or less fair to say that both Governors Kathleen Blanco (D-LA) and Ernie Fletcher (R-KY) are likely to be defeated in 2007 as Governor Haley Barbour (R-MS) is re-elected?
I’d probably agree, any incumbent Democrat would be at risk in Louisiana after the population shifts that where caused by Katrina and having received much of the blame for the ineffective response to the disaster Blanco’s position is impossible though it should be noted that, in no small part thanks to “Ray - sh*t for brains - Nagin” endorsement of Bobby Jindal Blanco was in 03 not too dependent on the black vote in New Orleans, but that’s really besides the point, she’ll lose and she’ll probably lose to Bobby Jindal.
The best thing for the Democrats might be to oust Blanco and run Lt.Governor Mitch Landrieu instead he’s a solid campaigner, a Landrieu and not a discredited political force like Blanco – another possibility could be tempting John Breaux back to public life, he has mulled over runs for governor in the past and he might be convinced to run, what more if he ran he’d win.
In all likelihood though Blanco gets nominated and gets soundly beaten by Bobby Jindal.
In Kentucky it’s a totally discredited Republican incumbent who’ll probably be running and almost certainly be going down to defeat.
Who is Montgardio? I don't know what to make of his close run at Bunning, should be one disappointed at his failing to defeat a senile, completely inept opponent or marvel at how close he came to beating a respected incumbent riding on Bush's coattails in a nowadays heavily Republican state?
The Democrat’s in the state don’t have a bad bench, Ben Chandler ran for Governor in 03 and lost, then ran and was elected to congress and has been state AG and Auditor – perhaps the best qualified and most likely candidate, though he has become something of a leading figure within the congressional blue dog collalition and might not want to give up his prospects there.
After Chandler there are two other potentially very strong candidates the former Lt.Governor Steve Henry and the current State Treasure Jonathan Miller both of whom would win fairly easily and as has been said Miller seems pretty keen to run anyway.
Dan Mongiardo is a guy who initially I wrote off, I though that he must have been a liberal gadfly who got lucky and ran a self-destructing candidate close by default – that’s simply not true, Mongiardo did very well in the race and was a canny campaigner throughout the race, where he to run for Governor I think he might well win
But he would be a risk and he remains largely untested and when the Dems in KY can boast a deep bench of experienced candidates who would win I think it would be a risk best not taken – However I think that Mongiardo has a great future in the Democratic Party if he wants to pursues it, a run for another state wide office Sectary of State or State Treasurer would set him up well for a future run for higher office but 07 simply won’t and shouldn’t be his year.
Finally Mississippi, prior to Katrina Barbour seemed to in a tight fix but now after a huge surge in his popularity after his handling of the hurricane he seems to be doing ok… unfortunately while Katrina has permanently or at least semi-permanently shifted the political geography of neighbouring Louisiana, the impact on Mississippi’s political landscape has been more transitory and in 2007 Barbour’s conduct in the aftermath of the storm may seem like having been a long time ago.
I’d say that Barbour should probably win re-election but another factor that has to be taken into account is what happens should Trent Lott step down and Mike Moore win the Senate seat? This could embolden other strong Democratic figures in the state to run against him both AG Jim Hood (a protégé of Moore’s) and former Governor Ray Mabus are both thought to be tempted to run if the race seems competive and a potentially intriguing possibility could be that even if Hood and Mabus pass on the race State Supreme Court Justice James Graves might also run and while I know both Hood and Mabus, Graves apart from being well qualified, a Democrat, Black and interested in a run for Governor is pretty much a blank to me (Harry…help?)
So Mississippi as things stands now will probably be held by Barbour should he run, but that could change and it’s really to early to tell in contrast I don’t see how the incumbents in either KY or LA survive barring an unforeseen intervention (i.e. Breaux or Landrieu running in LA)