N.Y.C. Mayor 2017: Giuliani vs. De Blasio?

[smoltchanov]

Giuliani would lose in a landslide.

A huge surge of voters from Staten Island could offset that. He did it in 1993.

And offset the colossal losses in the rest of the city? Because no way Guiliani is winning anywhere outside Staten Island after his insane support to Trump.

Queens. Manhattan. The Manhattan elite loves Giuliani. Forest Hills love Giuliani.

Manhattan loved Giuliani-97, but very unlikely to love Giuliany-17....

[smoltchanov]

Giuliani would lose in a landslide.

A huge surge of voters from Staten Island could offset that. He did it in 1993.

And offset the colossal losses in the rest of the city? Because no way Guiliani is winning anywhere outside Staten Island after his insane support to Trump.

Queens. Manhattan. The Manhattan elite loves Giuliani. Forest Hills love Giuliani.

Manhattan loved Giuliani-97, but very unlikely to love Giuliany-17....

Why not?He saved the borough from economic and social chaos after 9-11.

After 9-11 it was Bloomberg. Elected in Novenber 2001. And Giuliany was more socially liberal then, and no immigration extremist to boot. Manhattan is not simply liberal, but very liberal on almost all social issues..