I've decided to try something to see if it's successful.
The first challenge is this: to redraw the constituency boundaries of Wales so that the seats have similar electorates to those in England and Scotland
I’ve been playing about with this and there are a few points of note.
1. Preserved Counties – Unlike Scotland Wales has a series of preserved ‘counties’ used to define constituencies. The boundaries are different to those in use before 96 (Clywd is larger for example) So try and stick with these set divisions.
2. Yns Mon- Like the Isle of Wight (which is theoretically too large) and the Western Isles (which is theoretically too small) would Anglesey have a case to remain as one constituency, though below the quote (I happen to think that would be the case)
3. Powys: A tough one, too small for 2 constituencies, too large for 1: as it is a preserved county, should it be given 1 or 2 seats, or combined with a neighbouring county?
I’ve started with Clywd. I think (though I may be wrong) it would be entitled to 5 seats, down 2. I have expanded Wrexham slightly west and south east (taking in the former detatched part of Flynt) .Alyn and Deeside is surprisingly large for a Welsh constituency at present, but was extended northward. Then it got tricky as I neared the coast. I decided it would be best to create a long thin coastal constituency taking in most of the coast of Conwy, and a second taking in a small part of Conwy, most of the existing Vale of Clywd constituency apart from the south and part the coast of Flintshire. This left a large final constituency taking in everything else; inland and rural Clywd.
There
could be a case for having the whole of Denbighsire as one constituency, but that messed up neighbouring Conwy
It looked odd (as these changes can do if you look at Scotland!) but seemed the best solution.
(I’ll post the map later
![Smiley](https://talkelections.org/FORUM/Smileys/classic/smiley.gif)
)
Looking ahead, I can see Ceredigion being extended southwest along the north Pembrokeshire coast, similar to its pre 97 boundaries but extending even further.
----------------
What do you think? Anyone willing to give it a go and post maps for comparison?
I'm going to tackle the Welsh Valleys..that will probably be the most difficult and in reality changes could be quite controversial