You are put on the jury. How do you decide/act?

[True Federalist (진정한 연방 주의자)]

Option 2.  If the weapon used had been something more distinctly a weapon, option 1, but using a nail file is pretty indicative that the woman was not acting from a rational decision to harm the judge.  Might could have convicted of involuntary manslaughter if that had been an option, but not voluntary.