Wow, what a balanced and non-hackish list.
I won't argue that my list is clearly written from a Republican perspective. After all, this is the "Individual Politics" part of the forum. Personally, I don't really have a ton of respect for any president who supported abortion after 1973 and that is represented quite well on my list. I don't want to sidetrack this thread but if you want an explanation, there it is. I think mine is at least somewhat fair if you ignore every president chronologically after LBJ.
Perhaps it would be interesting to "average" everyone's lists once a few more people post and get a more non-ideological one.