Will The Hobbit end up "rotten"?

[Insula Dei]

Also, I love the sound of the title of this thread. Just, you know, phonetically.

Spoken like a true Tolkien fan.

Cellar door. Cellar door. Cellar door.

Tolkien was fond of quoting that and influential in popularizing it (certainly more so than Donnie Darko, since everybody old enough and not wholly clueless knew the line by then), but he didn't think it up himself.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cellar_door#History

Just when you go trough the pains of looking up a wikipedia article to get at some people on an internet message board, some random german guy gets in before you without as much as providing a link. Typical.