Liberals/lefties who act like this bill is pointless because it's not left-wing enough for them really annoy me. The point of passing social policy like this is not to prove a point or something, it's to help people and make society better. This bill does that. It expands health insurance coverage to tens of millions of people who didn't have it before. Those are real people, real human beings who can now afford to go to the doctor and treat diseases and ailments that they couldn't before. This policy is only "awful" to idealistic middle-class left-wingers on the internet who are completely removed from the reality of the people whose lives will be materially better because of this legislation.
I actually fully agree with this post. When I looked back on my initial thoughts, I was surprised that I said something so harsh against a piece of legislation that I still zealously defend because of the major impacts it will make in the lives of millions. It's one of the few reasons that I'm proud to consider myself a Democrat and an Obama supporter at this point. At the same time though, do you honestly think that this bill was constructed well as far as long term policy goes? My concerns aren't that it doesn't introduce a single player system or a public option (it was moronic to expect that to happen), my concerns are that it doesn't properly address the skyrocketing costs of care that are strangling the system and that "Obamacare" is doomed to failure in the same way that the health care system would be without it.
No, it wasn't. Obama had the political capital to push that through and supermajorities in both houses. The game wasn't necessarily going to be won, but it would certainly have been worth playing.
Imagine how intense the ad war against the bill would have been if Obama actively pushed for the legislation that we desire. It would have died a quick death after the barrage of misleading information and spooky talking points that would fill the airwaves.
In my opinion the risk was worth taking but I'd give it very slim odds and it more than likely would have meant that the failure of a broad reform.
Are you saying that the right's cultural hegemony is so strong as to never be possibly challenged ? Sadly, you might be right. But any time we renounce to challenge it for this reason, we actually make it stronger. Why would anyone support a public option if even the supposedly left-wing party doesn't ? The saddest thing is that polls showed that a health care reform
with public option would have been way more popular than the one actually passed.