Who would you have voted for in...?

[Erc]

Well, considering that he's voting for the Whig / Republican each time, it's not that hard to predict.

For Me;

1824 - Jackson
1828 - Jackson
1832 - Wirt
1836 - Harrison
1840 - Harrison
1844 - Polk
1848 - Cass
1852 - Pierce
1856 - Buchanan
1860 - Douglas
1864 - Lincoln
1868 - Grant
1872 - Grant
1876 - Tilden
1880 - Garfield
1884 - Cleveland
1888 - Cleveland
1892 - Cleveland
1896 - Palmer
1900 - McKinley
1904 - Parker
1908 - Taft
1912 - Wilson
1916 - Hughes
1920 - Cox
1924 - Davis
1928 - Hoover
And Republicans from there on out.

Essentially, I'm a Democrat (or Mugwump) until Al Smith runs...with the exception of 1832-1840 where Jackson personally alienates me from the party (I hate Clay too, hence the vote for Wirt)...1864-1872 I'm convinced by bloody shirt arguments, 1880 I just love Garfield, I can't stand Bryan so I vote for the Gold Democrats in 96 and hold my nose and vote for McKinley in '00 and Taft in '08.  Wilson loses my trust by '16, and by '28 the Democrats have shifted so far to the left I can't support them anymore.

[Erc]

I can't stand either McKinley (McKinley Tariff, anyone) or Bryan (proto-communist inflationary nutjob [without even getting into his later role in the Scopes Monkey case]).

Hence, the vote for Palmer in 1896.

[Erc]

You can vote for Truman in the primaries...

[Erc]

Tsk, tsk...

Let's see some 19th Century stuff here--those are the interesting ones...

[Erc]

I'm going to add my post-1928 and pre-1824 votes, as well...

1789:  Washington / Adams
1792:  Washington / Clinton
1796:  Jefferson (probably)
1800:  Jefferson
1804:  Jefferson
1808:  Madison
1812:  Clinton (probably)
1816:  Monroe
1820:  Monroe

1932:  Hoover
1936:  Hoover
1940:  FDR (probably)
1944:  Dewey
1948:  Dewey
1952:  Ike
1956:  Ike (probably)
1960:  Nixon (probably)
1964:  Goldwater
1968:  Nixon
1972:  Nixon (probably)
1976:  Ford
1980:  Reagan
1984:  Reagan
1988:  Bush
1992:  Bush (probably)
1996:  Dole
2000:  Bush
2004:  Bush