I'd probably vote against his confirmation, if that's what you're asking.
What concerns me more right now though, is not whether he is confirmed or rejected but that Senators' right to confirm or reject him based on whatever criteria they deem fit is upheld. If they want to take in the views of their constituents or the likely policy outcomes of a justice's position, I believe that is fully within their constitutional right and their right as members of the Senate to do so. And further, that all idealism aside, the practical reality of our Supreme Court for most of the past century or even beyond has made taking into account these other factors not only rightful but important.
I am certainly positive that President Bush took these factors into account while he was making his selections himself, knowing that they would be on everyone's mind. It is important to the health of the process that all concerned do not hide the truth or allow elephants to sit in the room without acknowledgement. It is no sin for the thoughts of men to escape their lips. It is no travesty for truth to be aired to the light of day.
The most interesting thing here, that nobody is really talking about, is how assuming that Alito is confirmed, the Democratic strategy on judges has completely failed.
Up until pretty recently, there was trepidation about what would happen if Bush appointed a truly conservative judge. Democrats clearly wanted to force Bush to appoint someone in the mold of O'Connor by creating this mythical requirement that a president not be able to move a court ideologically with his appointments, a requirement they never applied to themselves when they held the White House.
But now Bush has appointed two conservatives in a row, after one misstep that I think may have been planned. One has already been handily confirmed, and the other appears about to be confirmed.
Democrats were forced to back off their filibustering threats, and at this point don't dare to filibuster Alito. So it seems their scare tactics have not worked, as a majority of Americans seem to favor Alito's confirmation, and strident opposition to him is identified as a far left position.
Poll
