1948 Eisenhower - Marshall - Patton

[Lincoln Republican]

Eisenhower and Marshall require DC experience in a Vice Presidential running mate.

Both pick experienced, respected, and capable Senators.

Eisenhower picks Senator Arthur Vandenberg of Michigan.

Marshall picks Senator Millard Tydings of Maryland.

Patton picks accomplished former Governor of Alabama, Chauncey Sparks.

The election is not close, however.

Although all are war heroes, Eisenhower is recognized as the commander who led the 
allied forces to victory.  Coupled with the fact the Democrats had held the Presidency since 1933, results in a big Eisenhower win.

Eisenhower's immense charisma and popularity prove to be unbeatable.

Eisenhower/Vandenberg                    308
Marshall/Tydings                                 185
Patton/Sparks                                       38
 

[Lincoln Republican]

I had thought of Earl Warren for Ike's VP as well, and he would have been a good pick, as you point out.

As you know, Warren was Dewey's actual VP pick in 1948.

I opted for Vandenberg, however, as I believe Eisenhower, lacking political and DC experience, would have wanted someone with these qualifications, and Vandenberg fits the bil, experienced, intelligent, accomplished, respected on both sides of the aisle.

Warren did have political experience, of course, but he did lack DC experience.  Vandenberg knew his way around Congress.