More thoughts on the VRA

[Brittain33]

We might as well start hiving out separate ballots based on race. Apparently one can only be represented by someone who looks like him or her.

I know you're being sarcastic, but it's important to remember that the current interpretation of VRA districts has absolutely nothing to say about the race of the person elected, only if that person is the candidate of the community's choice.

[Brittain33]

Fundamental to citizenship is the right of self-identity and self-expression. 

I never expected a gerrymandering thread to rest on Kennedy's opinion in Lawrence v. Texas.

[Brittain33]

  Northern representatives were well aware of the effect of the removal of the 3/5 rule, and were disappointed that Southern states hadn't disenfranchised more voters. 

Do you have any quotes from the historical record for that? I believe you, it would be interesting to read them.

[Brittain33]

  Northern representatives were well aware of the effect of the removal of the 3/5 rule, and were disappointed that Southern states hadn't disenfranchised more voters. 

Do you have any quotes from the historical record for that? I believe you, it would be interesting to read them.

I read through a lot of the debate on the 1872 apportionment bill, but didn't come across anything.

It may have been in the debate on the 14th Amendment, where there was concern that the losing side in the Civil War would gain additional political power.

Cool. Let me know what you find.