1789 George Washington
1792 Thomas Jefferson
1796 Thomas Jefferson
1800 Thomas Jefferson
1804 Thomas Jefferson
1808 James Madison
1812 Dewitt Clinton
1816 Rufus King
1820 James Monroe
1824 William Harris Crawford (perhaps, Don't really enough about him)
1828 Andrew Jackson
1832 Andrew Jackson (not in retrospect though)
1836 Martin Van Buren
1840 Martin Van Buren
1844 James Birney
1848 Martin Van Buren
1852 John Parker Hale
1856 John Fremont
1860 Stephen Douglas
1864 Abraham Lincoln
1868 <no vote>
1872 Victoria Woodhall (Equal Rights) - Why not?
1876 Samuel Tilden
1880 James Baird Weaver
1884 Grover Cleveland
1888 Grover Cleveland
1892 Grover Cleveland
1896 John McAuley Palmer
1900 Wharton Baker
1904 Alton B. Parker
1908 William Jennings Bryan
1912 Eugene Debs
1916 Allan Benson
1920 Eugene Debs
1924 Robert Lafollete
1928 Al Smith (Though NOT in retrospect)
1932 Franklin Delano Roosevelt
1936
1940
1944 Franklin Delano Roosevelt
1948 Henry Wallace
1952 Fredrick Poehl (Greenback)
1956
1960
1964 <no vote>
1968 Dick Gregory
1972 George McGovern
1976 Eugene McCarthy
1980 Edward Clark
1984
1988 Eugene McCarthy
1992 Ross Perot
1996 Ross Perot or Ralph Nader or Harry Browne
2000 Harry Browne
2004 David Cobb
Those I left blank I wasn't sure about - need to know more about the third parties.