Has the Reformation gone too far?
No. Once religion (Catholicism, the Latin Church, etc.) ceased to be an arm of the Government, and its worship ceased to be enforced, then what you see in the O.P. is perfectly expected. God always tells everyone something different, see. 
LOL. You are a history student, right?
Haha, was, past tense. Good days. Late Medieval, Renaissance, history of science (Margaret Cavendish was a fascinating person), Milton generally.
So then are you familiar with
Cuius regio, eius religio and its meaning in the context of the Reformation?
