I think the bad thing about what Gutman said is his implication that Muslim Antisemitism should not be condemned because it stems from Israel's actions. Antisemitism doesn't happen in a vacuum, there is always some reason but that doesn't mean it shouldn't be condemned.
And I don't know what your problem is with the weekly standard, they were merely copying an article from Ynet, so you should complain about them first if you have a problem with the way the article was written.
I suppose you'd also say that anybody who hates America should be condemned regardless of the reason for it as well.
Or maybe it would be more reasonable to say that sometimes nations do things that piss people off, and rather than saying "stop hating!", the 'hated' nation could do a little self reflection and try to improve relations that way.
