Claysville is less than an hour away from Pittsburgh, the choice is obvious.
An hour away from Pittsburgh is quite far away from Pittsburgh. Once you get past 40ish minutes away from Pittsburgh, it is rural.
I don't know that area, but it also looks like they're asking for way too much. The listing has been on and off of the market for the better part of a decade without a sale. I see nearby sold listings for livable older houses with plenty of personalty for under $300k. You could get a nice old house along with dozens of acres in that area for what they're asking for here.
Yeah this has been up since September of last year and I am not a huge fan of that house for those aforementioned reasons. Also, I can't imagine the internet being good in Claysville.