Which state is more socially liberal?

[ottermax]

and yet AZ is the only one that voted against a gay marriage ban. tough to decide. Arizona has loud conservatives, but a soft liberal set; CO is similar, but has a more liberal reputation and has changed recently into a more liberal area. Pennsylvania has liberal roots, but seems quite conservative. Michigan seems to have a liberal set of institutions, but remains quite socially conservative as well.

I'd say Michigan or Colorado, but all 4 are very similar in the actual amount of social liberalness that exists.