Non Partisan Redistricting.

[Torie]

Who draws the districts in your perfect world Muon2?  Anybody can draw them and submit them to a "small group," and the "small group" then picks one the comports with the law?  I understand the idea for tight rules to leash discretion to only that which to disallow creates more problems than it solves, but I am bit confused by your description of the implementation process.

[Torie]

It would be nice to have a clear statement of what the exact role of regions is, vis a vis county/transportation link splits. How does inserting the concept of regions end up with better maps with a system that would apply to all 50 states?  Is part of it an attempt to respect metro regions even when it ends up with more county splits.  The mathematics of this all is quite daunting.