Did Bush underperform in Texas?

[One Term Floridian]

No Bush performed solidly in TX. Reagan’s margins are completely irrelevant here because he nearly won a coast-to-coast landslide, whereas W won a squeaker in 2000 and a close race in 2004. Just look at TX’s margins before and after he was President and you’ll see that in 2000 & 2004 he got one of the biggest home state bumps in recent memory. This home state effect turned TX from a Likely R state into essentially a titanium R state on both the local and federal levels until the rise of Donald Trump.

1988: R+12.6
1992: R+3.4
1996: R+4.9
2000: R+21.3
2004: R+22.9
2008: R+11.8
2012: R+15.8
2016: R+9

[One Term Floridian]

No Bush performed solidly in TX. Reagan’s margins are completely irrelevant here because he nearly won a coast-to-coast landslide, whereas W won a squeaker in 2000 and a close race in 2004. Just look at TX’s margins before and after he was President and you’ll see that in 2000 & 2004 he got one of the biggest home state bumps in recent memory. This home state effect turned TX from a Likely R state into essentially a titanium R state on both the local and federal levels until the rise of Donald Trump.

1988: R+12.6
1992: R+3.4
1996: R+4.9
2000: R+21.3
2004: R+22.9
2008: R+11.8
2012: R+15.8
2016: R+9

Also TX's PVI each cycle:
1988: R+4
1992: R+8
1996: R+13.5
2000: R+22
2004: R+20.5
2008: R+19
2012: R+20
2016: R+11

Yep and as for Reagan:

1980: R+3
1984: R+8.7

W dominated in TX, ‘nuff said lol