I turned off Poor Things after the first 30 minutes because it was stupid and embarrassing, so I can't judge Emma Stone's performance fairly, but from what I saw I thought she was kind of bad. Maybe that was just the writing. I'm assuming (or at least hoping) that it got better as it went along.
Good call! It's effectively just a never ending montage of sex scenes and once in a while they'll take a break for Emma Stone to talk about "philosophy" "socialism" or "reading". Put them in quotes since saying the words is pretty much all she has to say about them. I guess if they'd expanded on any of those subjects at all she wouldn't have been able to have sex every ten minutes.
It's pretty much a soft core porn movie with better direction and production values. Which contrary to the "puritan" accusation fans of the movie make whenever anyone points this out, I don't have any moral problem with. I just don't think porn is "great art" or needs to get awards nominations.
Anyway, to rank the nominees-
1. The Holdovers
2. Killers of the Flower Moon
3. American Fiction
4. Oppenheimer
5. Past Lives
6. Zone of Interest
7. Maestro
8. Poor Things
NS Barbie or Anatomy of a Fall