Of course, I still like my map (https://districtr.org/plan/96349) more than any of these. That said, these final options are far superior to some of the absolutely hideous options that the commission was pondering earlier on. (It was also quite predictable that they would rather go for 2 majority-minority districts than take my approach, even though mine should still be totally VRA-compliant, so I'm not surprised about that.) I wouldn't be too upset with any of them, even though the Kalamazoo-GR district in the Apple plan really is quite dubious and Wahlberg's district reaching both Lake Michigan and Lake Erie is not really ideal as far as compactness goes.
You appear to have an 80% black district which is packing.
