Safe D (sane).
Clinton: 59%
Trump: 35%
Johnson: 4%
Other: 2%
NY is actually one of only a handful of states where I could see Stein edging out Johnson. She very nearly did so back in 2012.
Johnson is on the ballot as both a Libertarian and with the Independence Party (granted they're separate elector slates unlike the other multiparty candidates like Trump and Clinton). I would be so sure of him losing to Stein in terms of the combined popular vote.
Also, Safe D. Anyone who says it isn't at this point is just crazy.