1988: Massachusetts Miracle
Michael Dukakis/Al Gore 277 EV 45,066,889 49.09%
George Bush/Dan Quayle 261 EV 45,639,667 49.72%
Lenora Fulani/Various 0 EV 673,861 0.73%
Ron Paul/Andre Marrou 0 EV 419,139 0.46%
Played as Dukakis/Gore on impossible. Ran to the middle on just about every issue, and tried to hammer Bush. Only won Michigan by 18,000 votes, Colorado by 20,000 votes, and Montana by 4,000 votes. Interestingly, Louisiana was the closest state, and it went to Bush by a grand total of 74 votes! Also of note is that no state gave either candidate more than 60%, though D.C did give Dukakis 76% of its votes.
https://www.americanhistoryusa.com/campaign-trail/game/823765