Atheist/Atheist
Fundies believe that anyone who belongs to any religion other than Christanity or Judaism is actually worshipping the Devil (and while they believe Jews worship the real God, it doesn't matter because God doesn't listen to their prayers). Therefore, an atheist would be preferable to them as someone they consider a Satanist. There goes the GOP base.
More Americans would vote for a homosexual over an atheist, at least I saw that in a poll once.
Despite that, there are people on this form dumb enough to actually think I would lose to an atheist or Muslim Republican.