Ninth Circuit rules Prop 8 unconstitutional.

[J. J.]

Ironically, I was listening to Diana Ross's Upside Down while reading the decision.  

The decision does seem fairly narrowly tailored, leaving open the possibility that there isn't a Federal constitutional right.  It went far below that standard.  

I agree that the judge's orientation is irrelevant.  

I tend to think it will ultimately be a states rights issue (as is cousin marriage and age of consent).