|
Title: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: GM Team Member and Senator WB on September 30, 2019, 11:06:12 AM It can be experience based, partisan based, whatever! Just post 'em.
Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: morgankingsley on September 30, 2019, 11:41:27 PM Assuming we can't appoint ourselves, lol, let's start:
Old School Republican, Xing, Progressive Pessimist, President Johnson, Fuzzy Bear, DKbator -or whatever it is-, Peebs, PSOL, and Perciles Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: S019 on October 02, 2019, 06:11:10 PM Let's have a 4-4-1 Scotus
The Liberals IceSpear Xingkerui Bagel23 Politician The Conservatives MTTreasurer Old School Republican Calthrina950 Rogue Beaver The Swing Vote Thunder98 Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: PSOL on October 02, 2019, 10:56:16 PM Antonio V
JacobinAmerican Mr. Reactionary Koharu Peebs Badger Sunrise Hammy Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: I Can Now Die Happy on October 02, 2019, 10:59:34 PM NYC Millennial Minority
Sanchez PiT TJ in Oregon RFayette Nuke thr33 Lechasseur Token Liberal: olawakandi Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: Okay, maybe Mike Johnson is a competent parliamentarian. on October 02, 2019, 11:08:18 PM Hamilton
kenyanobama Atheist2006 Einzige DWPERRY Libertas DownWithTheLeft poundingtherock kobidobidog Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: OSR stands with Israel on October 02, 2019, 11:18:38 PM Conservative:
TJ in Oregon PiT North Carolina Yankee Muon Liberal: Harry S Truman True Federalist Badger Illiniwek Swing Vote: Torie Tried to go with as many Lawyers as possible or people who post detailed posts about history Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: Orser67 on October 02, 2019, 11:32:28 PM Left:
Adam Griffin brucejoel99 Kalwejt SteveRogers Right: RealisticIdealist RINO Tom dead0man Old School Republican Unknown: Skill and Chance Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: Dr. MB on October 02, 2019, 11:41:22 PM I'll make it "balanced" or whatever so
The Walrus Sestak Leinad Adam Griffin Tech Timmy NC Yankee Fudotei LouisvilleThunder Mr Reactionary Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: Leinad on October 03, 2019, 12:21:23 AM Tried to go with lawyers + people who seem "very smart"
Truman Adam Averroes Spenstar Bacon King myself because why not lol Dereich NCYankee Mr. R Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: lfromnj on October 03, 2019, 01:19:23 AM 9 clones of MarkD
Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: Kingpoleon on October 03, 2019, 10:52:18 PM Torie
Badger Dereich Mark D RFayette Mr. Reactionary TJ DC RINO Tom If packing it? Toss smilo and Lumine in. Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: Former President tack50 on October 04, 2019, 02:33:49 AM I would make an all foreign posters court, having people with little idea about the US taking judicial decisions sounds fun :P
Also a seemingly balanced court Wyman/Parrotguy Windjammer Urutzizu Brughmger2 Lakigigar Poirot DavidB Lechasseur Lumine Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: morgankingsley on October 04, 2019, 03:40:48 AM I would make an all foreign posters court, having people with little idea about the US taking judicial decisions sounds fun :P Also a seemingly balanced court Wyman/Parrotguy Windjammer Urutzizu Brughmger2 Lakigigar Poirot DavidB Lechasseur Lumine Lol lit Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: Thunder98 🇮🇱 🤝 🇵🇸 on October 05, 2019, 11:06:25 PM I would expand the Scotus to 20 seats with a lot of ideological diversity
LouisvilleThunder IceSpear Nathan TJ DPKDebator Rfayette S019 Sanchez fhtagn Oregon Blue Dog MB MT Treasurer Lechessar Young Texan The Saint ON Progressive Libertpaulian Sir Mohamed TechTim xingkerui Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: UlmerFudd on October 22, 2019, 11:28:17 PM Yankee
Dereich PiT muon Reactionary MarkD Averroes Spenstar MB Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: 538Electoral on October 24, 2019, 02:23:20 PM 4 Left-leaners.
Politician Councilman Laki IceSpear 6 Right-leaners SN2903 Nuke Atlas: Consistently Wrong InvisibleTrump redeagleofficial Yellowhammer Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: SingingAnalyst on December 15, 2019, 07:44:39 PM Fuzzy Bear
Calthrina950 My Immortal SN2903 Progressive Pessimist Kingpoleon brucejoel1999 Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: Kingpoleon on December 16, 2019, 03:47:27 PM Fuzzy Bear Calthrina950 My Immortal SN2903 Progressive Pessimist Kingpoleon brucejoel1999 Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: HillGoose on December 16, 2019, 04:54:15 PM Da left:
Darklordoftech Blairite Lourdes brughmger2 Da right: Goldwater lfromnj SunriseAroundTheWorld fhtagn RINO Tom this group would render some interesting as hell decisions I bet. Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: 😥 on December 19, 2019, 10:12:18 AM MT Treasurer
OSR Lechausser DavidB S019 President Johnson brucejoel1999 Parrotguy Kingpoleon Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: Antonio the Sixth on December 20, 2019, 01:58:33 AM Expand the court to 12 Justices. Tied decisions are resolved in favor of the government actor.
Chief Justice: Nathan Associate Justices: Kalwejt Averroes LD Smith National Progressive Mr. X RINO Tom MarkD Muon TJ RFayette Goldwater Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: KoopaDaQuick 🇵🇸 on January 01, 2020, 06:36:39 PM lefties:
olawakandi Suburban New Jersey Communist AudmanOut BRTD Wulfric/Dwarven Dragon conservabois: HillGoose (chief justice) Greedo The Hunter [insert R-FL avatar here] Yellowhammer fair and balanced Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: MarkD on January 02, 2020, 10:00:17 AM I'm honored and touched! I'm about to have a Sally Field moment!
Here's my list: Ernest/True Federalist brucejoel99 Torie lfromnj (returning the honor) Wulfric/Dwarven Dragon NOVA Green Calthrina950 Muon 538Electoral That's 3 red avatars, 2 blue, and 4 others. Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: LAKISYLVANIA on February 27, 2020, 03:43:15 PM ReaganClinton20xx
Kalwejt John Dule Brucejoel99 President Johnson Lechasseur RINO Tom Grassr00ts MT Treasurer. Who I think would genuinely good SCOTUS members. I would also function better in a cabinet position than as a SCOTUS member honestly. You need to put your ideology aside as a SCOTUS member. Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: President Punxsutawney Phil on March 31, 2020, 08:48:56 PM Reagente
PiT Badger Mr. Reactionairy Lief Spenstar Vivaportugalhabs President_Johnson FuzzyBear Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: Senator-elect Spark on April 26, 2020, 10:09:38 PM Tmth
MT Treasurer MikeWells Grassr00ts PiT Reagente FuzzyBear Lechasseur Fairbol Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: Kleine Scheiße on May 01, 2020, 07:59:16 AM i'm douglas lmao
Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: PSOL on May 01, 2020, 11:29:23 PM Left:
Antonio V—Head Justice JacobinAmerican warandwar Cassandra Koharu Peebs Badger Right: MarkD—head Justice Dead0Man Sunrise Marty Penn_Quaker_Girl Reagante Tmth Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: At-Large Senator LouisvilleThunder on May 05, 2020, 04:13:29 PM From left to right
MB Windjammer Santander Fuzzy Bear North Carolina Yankee Mr. Reactionary TJ in Oregon PiT Reagente Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: Virginiá on May 05, 2020, 10:08:51 PM I'm honored and touched! I'm about to have a Sally Field moment! Here's my list: Ernest/True Federalist brucejoel99 Torie lfromnj (returning the honor) Wulfric/Dwarven Dragon NOVA Green Calthrina950 Muon 538Electoral That's 3 red avatars, 3 blue, and 3 others. Admitting to such blatant cronyism! This is terrible. Impeach! IMPEACH! Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: OBD on May 06, 2020, 10:30:23 PM Left
Truman MB S019 President Johnson Jimmy7812 Center/Right Old School Republican LouisvilleThunder Penn_Quaker_Girl lfromnj Sorry if I left out anyone. This Supreme Court would be pretty moderate, and pretty intriguing. Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: DINGO Joe on May 08, 2020, 02:12:34 AM Virginia
TG Badger Joe Republic Skunk A sensible center-left majority to actual run things smilo dead0man santander to provide god knows what dissenting opinions Technocracy Timmy or HCP to keep things fun Also, it's about as diverse of a group as your gonna get with Atlas. Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: Grassroots on May 09, 2020, 04:21:52 PM Ses
PSOL Santander RINO Tom lfromnj Mr. Reactionary Ftaghn Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: Santander on May 22, 2020, 01:39:33 AM Virginia - judge, jury, executioner.
Why? Because I am shamelessly sucking up to become a mod. Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: Chancellor Tanterterg on May 22, 2020, 01:06:32 PM Virginia - Chief Justice
Dereich Badger Nathan Brittain33 Lumine Gass3268 Adam Griffin Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: MarkD on December 26, 2021, 06:05:37 AM Bump.
(OTOH, Harvey Fierstein said that we should never fish for compliments in polluted waters. So should I really bump this thread? Too late, I did it.) Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: West_Midlander on December 26, 2021, 10:25:00 AM reagente
fhtagn Chips TimTurner Conservatopia GregTheGreat Peebs NCYankee - Chief Justice LT (effectively a 6-1-2 majority for conservatives with TimTurner joining conservatives on some social issues, leading many decisions to likely be 8-1) Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: Badger on December 27, 2021, 08:07:47 PM In an unabashed attempt to recreate the Warren court:
Mr. X Lief Joe Republic (whine about him being a meanie to conservatives if you want, he researches what he posts better Then the large majority of posters here, and Is better than pretty much any conservative poster). Georgia Moderate (a perfect "MINO" To earn me wholly undeserved bi partisan cred) Virginia ( 1st female Chief Justice). Texas Gurl ( Although having 2 women on the court is hardly balanced overall, for Atlas it's practically a gynocracy) Afleitch ( Not simply filling The Secret requirement of having a token gay Scotsman at the highest levels of government, though he performs that task well too) Brittain33 Gass ( In case I haven't sucked up to the mod's enough) Honorable mention: North Carolina Yankee. Only downside as he would probably shift conservative again from being in the constant minority among liberals, and hes much more effective outside the court trying, however hopeless a battle, to install even a modicum of sanity and respect for democratic values in the trump era or Republican party. He'd be a waste on the court. Torie In addition to his streak of economic conservatism that led him to support Romney in 2012, I'd mostly be concerned he would Die too soon after appointment. ;D Chief court sketch artist: John Dule. Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: I spent the winter writing songs about getting better on December 27, 2021, 08:17:19 PM Chief Justice olawakandi
Associate Justices: Lief Scott bronz Nathan Fuzzy Bear ProudModerate2 darklordoftech Xahar Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: Badger on December 28, 2021, 01:27:58 AM Chief Justice olawakandi Associate Justices: Lief Scott bronz Nathan Fuzzy Bear ProudModerate2 darklordoftech Xahar I've officially determined your alignment is chaotic neutral. Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: PSOL on December 28, 2021, 01:29:41 PM While I would like for the Supreme Court to be abolished, my dream one is:
Warandwar-head justice King T’Chenka Laki Discovolante Third party HenryWallaceVP Ismail Pyro Hopefully most of the members have sense to abolish themselves after any sensible administration gets out of office Edit; forgot Franco ago and burritobr Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: Schiff for Senate on January 19, 2022, 02:31:31 PM I want interesting, intellectually stimulating debate and gridlock, so:
Christian Man (very independent-minded) THG (establishment conservative) GregTheGreat (establishment conservative) NC Yankee (interesting views) flyingmongoose (very moderately conservative) S019 (partially to aggravate the others) Olawakandi (so we can see what he really thinks) John Dule (pure libertarian) Frank (we need a COVID hawk) Come to think of it, this court is too conservative, so I will strike GregTheGreat (sorry, Greg, it was you or THG and I settled on THG because he is older and perhaps knows a bit more) and replace him with BRTD (all liberal, all the time) for: Christian Man (very independent-minded) THG (establishment conservative) NC Yankee (a different type of conservative) flyingmongoose (very moderately conservative) S019 (partially to aggravate the others, partially for a centre-left voice) Olawakandi (so we can see what he really thinks) John Dule (pure libertarian) Frank (we need a COVID hawk) Second amendment (this is really a double play on the term since Big Abe is for gun rights): Olawakandi is great, but now I think about it, I want a more interesting and divided court, so: Christian Man (very independent-minded) THG (establishment conservative) BRTD (all liberal, all the time) NC Yankee (a different type of conservative) flyingmongoose (very moderately conservative) S019 (partially to aggravate the others, partially for a centre-left voice) John Dule (pure libertarian) Frank (we need a COVID hawk) Lastly, though I disagree with him on a lot, it would be neat for a social conservative to be on the court (cue ExtremeRepublican), so I would replace Yankee with ER: Christian Man (very independent-minded) THG (establishment conservative) BRTD (all liberal, all the time) flyingmongoose (very moderately conservative) S019 (partially to aggravate the others, partially for a centre-left voice) Big Abraham (REVOLUTION!) John Dule (pure libertarian) Frank (we need a COVID hawk) FINAL DECISION: Christian Man (very independent-minded) THG (establishment conservative) BRTD (all liberal, all the time) ExtremeRepublican (I want a social conservative on there) flyingmongoose (very moderately conservative) S019 (partially to aggravate the others, partially for a centre-left voice) Big Abraham (REVOLUTION!) John Dule (pure libertarian) Frank (we need a COVID hawk) This would be an interesting court for sure, though it probably wouldn't agree with a lot of my views. Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: GregTheGreat657 on January 22, 2022, 06:45:48 PM I will try to relatively balance this court
The conservative wing: THG Conservatopia OSR The moderate wing: ChristianMan MarkD WestMidlander The liberal wing: TDAS04 Liam BigAbraham Honorable Mentions: Abdullah Chips PQG Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: Kahane's Grave Is A Gender-Neutral Bathroom on January 24, 2022, 09:10:59 PM ExtremeRepublican
Mr. Reactionary THG SirWoodbury BigSerg - Peebs RP McNm S019 BRTD Scott Actually, this is the only court I need: Olawakandi Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: NewYorkExpress on January 26, 2022, 12:50:49 AM Chief Justice: NYE (Obviously I'm going to appoint myself, otherwise what's the point of this exercise?)
Associate Justices: Torie Lumine UWS Virginia Fuzzy Bear S019 Texasgurl Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: John Dule on January 26, 2022, 02:51:36 AM Christian Man (very independent-minded) THG (establishment conservative) BRTD (all liberal, all the time) ExtremeRepublican (I want a social conservative on there) flyingmongoose (very moderately conservative) S019 (partially to aggravate the others, partially for a centre-left voice) Big Abraham (REVOLUTION!) John Dule (pure libertarian) Frank (we need a COVID hawk) Uh..... I respectfully decline this Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: Schiff for Senate on January 28, 2022, 11:04:30 PM Christian Man (very independent-minded) THG (establishment conservative) BRTD (all liberal, all the time) ExtremeRepublican (I want a social conservative on there) flyingmongoose (very moderately conservative) S019 (partially to aggravate the others, partially for a centre-left voice) Big Abraham (REVOLUTION!) John Dule (pure libertarian) Frank (we need a COVID hawk) Uh..... I respectfully decline this Yeah I imagine like 2 or 3 of these people would actually agree to serve on a court with the other 8 ;P Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: jamestroll on January 29, 2022, 11:32:31 AM Non swing voter chief justice
Associate justices Sirwoodbury Fhtagn Mr. Reactionary Var Beaver 2.0 One term Floridan Scott Myself jimmie Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: 支持核绿派 (Greens4Nuclear) on January 29, 2022, 01:11:20 PM Wanted to create an ideologically balanced court of posters whose views I respect, trust not to be hyper partisan hacks, and (if American) represent states I've lived in. Chief Justice: President Johnson (D-Germany). Associate Justice: xingkerui (D-Washington). Associate Justice: Pericles (D-New Zealand). Associate Justice: Beet (D-Texas). Associate Justice: Penn_Quaker_Girl (R-Texas). Associate Justice: RI (R-Washington). Associate Justice: NOVA Green (S-Oregon). Associate Justice: TJ the Mod (C-Oregon). Associate Justice: Chips (I-Ohio). Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: Kuumo on January 29, 2022, 02:26:49 PM The left:
Badger (Chief Justice) Crane Nathan brucejoel99 The median: GeorgiaModerate The right: Averroes North Carolina Yankee Dr. RI The libertarian wild-card: John Dule Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: Santander on January 30, 2022, 03:13:05 PM Badger (Chief Justice) Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: OSR stands with Israel on January 30, 2022, 03:29:39 PM Regente
Mr. Reactionary PIT TJ in Oregon North Carolina Yankee Harry S Truman True Federalist Western Dem Illiniwek Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: Vice President Christian Man on February 12, 2022, 01:15:47 PM Conservative:
Dr. RI Trustbuster Gregthegreat Fuzzy Bear DPKDebator Pure tossup: Chips Liberals: Olwankandi (Chief Justice) Abdullah Western Democrat Ye Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: MarkD on July 06, 2022, 08:48:49 PM I'm honored and touched! I'm about to have a Sally Field moment! Here's my list: Ernest/True Federalist Torie lfromnj (returning the honor) Wulfric/Dwarven Dragon NOVA Green Calthrina950 Muon 538Electoral That's 3 red avatars, 2 blue, and 4 others. I hereby revise this list in order to remove brucejoel99 from it. I don't know, yet, who else on Atlas I could choose to put on this list to replace him, but as of now I sure as blazes do not want bj99 to be on the Supreme Court. About 2 hours ago, bj99 posted an argument about the 9th Amendment that is absolutely the worst piece of drivel I've ever seen from, in particular, him. Whatever respect I used to have for his legal acumen, he just washed it away completely. Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: brucejoel99 on July 07, 2022, 10:31:51 AM Chief Justice: True Federalist Associate Justice: Nathan Associate Justice: SteveRogers Associate Justice: Mr. Reactionary Associate Justice: windjammer Associate Justice: Old School Republican Associate Justice: Associate Justice: brucejoel99 Associate Justice: lfromnj I hereby revise this list in order to remove MarkD from it. I don't know, yet, who else on Atlas I could choose to put on this list to replace him, but as of now I sure as blazes do not want MarkD to be on the Supreme Court. About 14 hours ago, MarkD posted an argument about my clapback of originalism's hypocritical 9th Amendment interpretation that is absolutely the worst piece of drivel I've ever seen from, in particular, him. Whatever respect I used to have for what I thought was his obviously idiosyncratic but, at least hitherto now, consistently objective legal acumen, he just washed it away completely. Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: Grumpier Than Uncle Joe on July 07, 2022, 11:12:20 AM The Left -
Nathan Georgia Moderate Badger Sir Mohamed The Center - Torie - I'm teetering on him being center. The Right - Fuzzy Mr. Reactionary OSR Me :) Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: Sir Mohamed on July 07, 2022, 11:46:22 AM From liberal to conservative:
- Western Democrat - Parrotguy - President Johnson - GeorgiaModerate - Penn Quaker Girl - Goldwater - That Conservative Guy - GregtheGreat657 Couldn't decide on the CJ, anyone of these would be fine. Think this SCOTUS would be relatively balanced and function well, because all of these are appear rational, calm and grown-up. Title: Re: Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members. Post by: Progressive Pessimist on July 07, 2022, 06:27:38 PM -Chief Justice: YE.
-Scott. -Xing. -Texasgurl. -Progressive Moderate. -Flying Mongoose. -John Dule. -North Carolina Yankee. -Penn Quaker Girl. I think this is a pretty balanced and rational court with diverse backgrounds. |