Read the links- the panel was flabbergasted at the fact that he entered her anally without using lube.
I'm assuming these events happened for the sake of argument because the outcomes that happened here would have occurred regardless of whether the claims were correct or not, which says a lot about the system's flaws. I also don't believe the redpiller garbage than any significant percentage of rape accusations are fake because rape is far more likely to occur but then go unreported than the other way around, and bringing it up at first instinct is just terrible victim blaming
MRAs and redpillers undeniably overstate the prevalence of false rape reports (which are a legitimate problem but are far outweighed by the under-reporting of rape), but presumption of innocence is not the same as "victim-blaming". That said, regardless of what actually happened here, Columbia's system is clearly incompetent and proof that criminal matters should be handled by law enforcement.