what if ? : proportionnal representation/closed party list/saint-laguë method

[Colbert]

the electoral district is, as in israel, the entire national area




   UKGBNI   
      
      
   TORY   235
   LABOUR   189
   WHIGH   150
   UKIP   20
   BNP   13
   SNP   11
   GREEN   6
   SINN FEIN   4
   UNIONIST   4
   CYMRU   4
   SDLP   3
   C&U   2
   ED   2
   ALLIANCE   1
   RESPECT   1
   TRAD.UNIONIST   1
   CHRISTIAN   1
   SCOT. GREEN   1
   HEALTH CONC.   1
   TU&SOC.   1
   
      
      
      
      
      
      
   FRANCE
      
   UMP   228
   PS   143
   MODEM   44
   FN   25
   PCF   25
   EXG   20
   EELV   19
   DVD   14
   NC   14
   DVG   11
   PRG   7
   MPF   7
   DIVERS   6
   CPNT   5
   DVE   4
   REGIONALISTS   3
   DVEXD   2
      
      577
      
      
   GERMANY   
      
   CDU   199
   SPD   174
   Linke   69
   FDP   59
   Grunen   57
   CSU   46
   NDP   11
   others   4
   EDP   2
   Piraten   1
   
      

      
      
      
   ITALIE   
      
   PDL   231
   PD   205
   LN   51
   UDC   35
   IDV   27
   SINISTRA ARC.   19
   LA DESTRA   15
   MPAS   7
   PS   6
   PCL   4
   SINISTRA CR.   3
   SVP   2
   NO ABORTO   2
   PIBC   2
   FORZA NUOVA   2
   PLI   2
   CONSUMATORI   2
   NO EURO   1
   LIGA VENETA   1

      
      
      
   SPAIN
      
   PP   158
   PSOE   102
   IULV   25
   UPYD   17
   CIU   15
   AMAIUR   5
   PNV   5
   ESQUERRA   4
   EQUO   3
   BNG   3
   CC   2
   COMPROMIS   2
   PACMA   2
   FAC   2
   EB   1
   PACMA   1
   PXC   1
   PRC   1
   GBAI   1




what intersting parliament we could have been !

[Teddy (IDS Legislator)]

CANADA

123 CPC
95 NDP
59 Liberal
19 Bloc
12 Green

[Teddy (IDS Legislator)]

And with D'Hondt
http://icon.cat/util/elections

124 CPC
95 NDP
59 LIB
18 BQ
12 GRN

[MaxQue]

Interesting than the NDP votes and seats are roughly proportionnal when the provincial seat distribution wasn't.

[Teddy (IDS Legislator)]

In addition. Note that under neither method would the CHP, with 19,218 votes gets seats. CHP is the 6th party. Note however that Indepenednt Candidate, James Ford, comes after the CHP, but before the MLP at 16,283, and Andre Arthur at 14,594. None of them come close to the some 47K that would be needed for a seat.