This honestly could not be easier:
Federalists -- Adams (is there another choice?)
Democratic-Republicans -- Madison
Whigs -- Tyler
Democrats -- FDR, Carter, LBJ
Republicans -- Lincoln, *huge gap* Ford, Eisenhower
Lincoln?
Why are you confused? The man fought an unnecessary war that started by violating the constitution, than violated the constitution at every turn of the war, issue a proclamation that aimed not to free anyone, but to keep Britian out of the war. All this while still finding the time to kill hundred of innocent Native Americans.