BRTD's opinion of the Catholic Charismatic Renewal?

[Simfan34]

it's just so un-scene

And that is all that matters.

What does that even mean?

I am disinclined towards charismaticism in general, even in our church I'm not too crazy when we sing the peppy songs written after 1980 and the major scale responses ("We prroclaaaaim your death oooo Lorddd..."). I've never been to a Latin mass, but I've been to a long Orthodox one; didn't understand a word but it was just amazing. I was in church when we sang a great song and I wondered why it was so good. I looked at the date- 1494- "ah, that's why". (It was O Filli et Filliae, if anyone asks)

[Simfan34]

Well, I speak Latin, so maybe I'm biased. But what were we singing the other week? It was something secular. I mean, we're Catholics, not Unitarians.

[Simfan34]

Nowadays one is happy when they somehow manage to produce an Adeste Fideles.

The first hymn I learnt!