Very out of the box but here goes nothing....
Bush/Cheney (R): 271 EVs, 47.9% PV
Gore/Lieberman (D): 266 EVs, 48.4% PV
Recount in Florida occurs but 5-4 decision in Bush v Gore stops recount and gives Bush the election
One faithless elector abstained because DC has lack of representation in congress
Green party candidate Ralph Nader gets 3% because Gore is perceived as too moderate
lol. What's next, some Illinois State Senator taking the Presidency away from the sitting first lady in 8 years? Come on, get real.
Gore/Graham vs. Liddy Dole/Bob Smith is probably going to be the ticket at this point. I wouldn't undercut Bill Bradley's chances though. He could pull off an upset.