1960- tough but Ill give it to Kennedy narrowly
1964- LBJ
1968- Wallace, but Nixon is 2nd
1972- Nixon obv
1976- Ford
1980- Reagan obv
1984- Reagan obv
1988- Bush Sr. very narrowly although neither candidates are "alpha males"
1992- Bush Sr.
1996- Clinton
2000- W Bush
2004- W Bush obv
2008- McCain
2012- Obama narrowly
2016- this shouldn't really count(only 1 male candidate) but Trump I would say
2020- Trump
It's funny that in many of these the actual military combat veteran is beaten by someone who wasn't (1964, 1972, 1996, 2000, 2004).