Clinton...barring a national landslide..which might put NY into play...
Rudy isn't going to win the Republicans NY, but he gives them some hope in NJ and CT...some...
and he might carry PA...
but New York? Highly unlikely.
Clinton would have to spend $$ in NY - which she would need elswhere and that'd make it interesting.
No, she wouldn't. Clinton solidly has the backing of upstate New York over Giuliani (upstaters hate the city and cityfolk), and New York City itself has less than fond memories of Giuliani. Unlike the rest of the country, NYC knew Giuliani before September 11th.