Where should the next NHL teams be?

[Badger]

Voted Seattle. Wouldn't mind Quebec. Still feel bad for Atlanta hockey fans.

Europe is a dream. Unlike dreamed NFL or MLB expansion, way too much competition from their many home-grown leagues.

[Badger]

Also, anyone who doesn't say Quebec City (or at least a Canadian city) should (figuratively) diaf.

Where beyond Quebec? I don't like the idea of Toronto or Montreal having a second team (could either support it, especially Montreal?). The remaining choices are Hamilton, which is probably too small a metro area to support an NHL team, and Saskatoon which is definitely not viable.

[Badger]

Also, anyone who doesn't say Quebec City (or at least a Canadian city) should (figuratively) diaf.

Where beyond Quebec? I don't like the idea of Toronto or Montreal having a second team (could either support it, especially Montreal?). The remaining choices are Hamilton, which is probably too small a metro area to support an NHL team, and Saskatoon which is definitely not viable.

Hamilton is about the size of Winnipeg, but is close enough to other mid-sized cities. One thing to remember is that this is Canada, and even a small market would make much more money than a large US sun belt market. (look at Winnipeg).

Plus, if NYC can have three teams, and LA of all places can have two teams, why shouldn't Toronto get a second team? The average Torontonian never gets to go to Leafs games, because they are always sold out. Mostly only the wealthy can manage to get tickets. (That's why so many Leafs fans make the trip to other cities to see the Leafs). There is a huge market for a second team in Toronto.

Incisive and persuasive. I knew Hamilton had a number of mid-sized (by Canadian standards ) cities nearby, but I didn't realize the city itself was about the size of Winnipeg.

My only quibble is LA =/= Anaheim.

But wait a minute, I remember seeing the Marlies play at home against Lake Erie on TV some months ago, and noticed it was woefully unattended game. I realize it's only AHL and just one game I saw, but how's their attendence? That may be at least somewhat indicative of how a second NHL team would do, right?

Checked Wiki, and there seems to have historically been some issues with Marlies attendence, so...

[Badger]

Also, anyone who doesn't say Quebec City (or at least a Canadian city) should (figuratively) diaf.

Where beyond Quebec? I don't like the idea of Toronto or Montreal having a second team (could either support it, especially Montreal?). The remaining choices are Hamilton, which is probably too small a metro area to support an NHL team, and Saskatoon which is definitely not viable.

Hamilton is about the size of Winnipeg, but is close enough to other mid-sized cities. One thing to remember is that this is Canada, and even a small market would make much more money than a large US sun belt market. (look at Winnipeg).

Plus, if NYC can have three teams, and LA of all places can have two teams, why shouldn't Toronto get a second team? The average Torontonian never gets to go to Leafs games, because they are always sold out. Mostly only the wealthy can manage to get tickets. (That's why so many Leafs fans make the trip to other cities to see the Leafs). There is a huge market for a second team in Toronto.

Incisive and persuasive. I knew Hamilton had a number of mid-sized (by Canadian standards ) cities nearby, but I didn't realize the city itself was about the size of Winnipeg.

My only quibble is LA =/= Anaheim.

But wait a minute, I remember seeing the Marlies play at home against Lake Erie on TV some months ago, and noticed it was woefully unattended game. I realize it's only AHL and just one game I saw, but how's their attendence? That may be at least somewhat indicative of how a second NHL team would do, right?

Checked Wiki, and there seems to have historically been some issues with Marlies attendence, so...

Toronto is notorious for not supporting minor league or junior league anything (the OHL has attempted to put junior teams in the Greater Toronto Area, and all have either moved or are struggling). A new NHL team wouldn't be minor league. From Facebook data, we know that only around 50% of hockey fans in Toronto are Leafs fans. That means the other 50% are up for grabs.

Interesting. I guess I can understand that dynamic. It's almost the reverse of Columbus-area football: People don't care that much for NFL football as they rabidly back the Bucks.

If the market is there as you say, what do you think the holdback to a second team has been?

[Badger]

Just remembering it is important hockey town.

"Town", not a city relative to other options. That's the key.

[Badger]

I wish the NHL would've let Pittsburgh move to Hamilton 10 years ago

DIAF. A big one.

Given that Pittsburgh is pretty much the single best city for hockey in America, basically along with Buffalo the only one whose proportionate level of fandom rivals Canadian cities... that would have been a horrible idea.  Yes, Hamilton probably ought to have a team.  It really really oughtn't be the Pens though.

Between the Lemieux are and the Crosby era, no one care about the Pens.

Other than Lemieux' temporary retirement from 1998-2000, the time period you describe is from 1984 to present.