I think I've done this before, but I can't find the thread. Regardless of who you voted for, what party would you have been a member of? I'll go first:
1789-1795: No Party
1795-1805: Federalist
1805-1824: Republican/Democratic-Republican
1824-1838: Whig
1838-1856: Independent
1856-1873: Republican
1873-1915: Democrat
1915-1995: Republican
1995-2005: Democrat
2005-Present: Independent (Possibly Republican)
My views have changed somewhat, so I'll give it another go:
1789-1795: No Party
1795-1805: Federalist
1805-1824: Republican/Democratic-Republican
1824-1838: Whig
1838-1856: Independent
1856-1873: Republican
1873-1901: Democrat
1901-1934: Republican
1934-Present: Democrat (though quite a few times I would have crossed party lines)